Choosing between the Ninja FG551 vs IG651 can be quite a challenge, especially since both appliances bring distinct benefits to the table. As someone who enjoys both grilling and experimenting with various cooking techniques, I’ve had the pleasure of using both these machines in my kitchen.
In this article, I will share my insights from using these grills and help you decide which one fits your needs better.
Is the Ninja FG551 a Good Option?
The Ninja FG551 is an excellent choice for anyone who loves grilling but doesn’t have the outdoor space to do so. With this grill, I’ve been able to replicate that smoky, outdoor flavor indoors. Whether it’s juicy burgers, grilled veggies, or seared steaks, the results have been fantastic.
The grill’s unique feature, the smart thermometer, is something I absolutely love—it takes the guesswork out of grilling. You set the doneness level, and it lets you know when your food is ready, which is perfect when cooking steak to that ideal medium-rare temperature.
What truly sets the Ninja FG551 apart is its versatility. It’s not just a grill; it’s a multi-functional cooker. It can air fry, bake, roast, and even broil. I’ve used it to make crispy fries with very little oil, which turned out golden and crunchy. If you’re someone who loves quick dinners without the hassle of using an oven, this is a fantastic tool.
What I Like:
- Smart Thermometer: No more overcooking steaks! The built-in thermometer is a game-changer, alerting you when your food has reached the desired doneness.
- Versatility: Whether grilling, air frying, or baking, the Ninja FG551 handles it all, making it a highly versatile kitchen companion.
- Easy Cleanup: With non-stick plates and dishwasher-safe components, cleaning up after cooking is a breeze.
- Compact Design: It’s the perfect size for a small kitchen. I don’t have to worry about it taking up too much counter space.
What Could Be Better:
- Loud Fan Noise: It can get a bit noisy, particularly in air fry mode. If you’re sensitive to sound, this could be a minor inconvenience.
- Pricey: While it’s a quality product, the price tag is a bit on the higher side compared to basic grills.
- Learning Curve: The controls are a bit tricky to get used to at first, especially when you’re trying to master all the different settings.
Recommendation: If you’re someone who loves grilled food but doesn’t have the luxury of outdoor space, the Ninja FG551 is an excellent choice. It’s ideal for apartment living or anyone who wants a space-saving appliance that can replace multiple kitchen gadgets.
However, if you’re on a tight budget or want a quieter option, you might want to consider something else.
“The best way to predict the future is to create it.” – Abraham Lincoln
Is the Ninja IG651 a Better Choice?
Now, the Ninja IG651 is where things get a bit more advanced. For those who want to explore more cooking methods, this model brings a lot to the table. I used it to grill chicken and veggies, and the results were just as great as grilling outdoors.
The key feature that really stands out for me is the Smart Cook System, which takes precision to the next level. You can select your preferred doneness, and the grill alerts you when your food is cooked to perfection. This feature, combined with the temperature probe, makes it almost impossible to overcook your food.
In addition to grilling, the IG651 excels at air frying, baking, broiling, roasting, and even dehydrating. I found it incredibly versatile and perfect for anyone who loves experimenting with new cooking techniques. Cleanup is simple thanks to the dishwasher-safe, non-stick grill plates. I appreciate that it saves me time in the kitchen, especially after I’ve cooked a meal and just want to relax.
What I Like:
- Smart Cook System: This feature makes it so easy to get your food just right. No need to second-guess whether your steak is done.
- Versatility: Grills, air fries, bakes, roasts, broils, and even dehydrates—this appliance does it all.
- Easy Cleanup: The grill plates are removable and dishwasher-safe, which is a huge plus for quick and hassle-free cleaning.
What Could Be Better:
- Bulky Size: The IG651 is a bit larger than the FG551, so it takes up more counter space. This could be an issue if you have a smaller kitchen.
- Learning Curve: With so many functions, it takes a little while to get comfortable with all the cooking modes.
- Pricey: This model costs more than the FG551, but given its added features, it may be worth the extra cost if you’ll use them frequently.
Recommendation: The Ninja IG651 is perfect for people who want a high-tech, versatile grill. If you love the idea of grilling indoors but also want to experiment with various cooking techniques, this is the right choice.
It’s great for busy individuals who want to make meals quickly and efficiently, especially during the colder months when outdoor grilling isn’t an option. However, if you have a smaller kitchen or are looking for something simpler and budget-friendly, the IG651 might feel like overkill.
“Success is the sum of small efforts, repeated day in and day out.” – Robert Collier
Detailed Comparison: Ninja FG551 vs IG651
I’ve used both grills extensively, and while they each excel in their own right, it’s important to understand how they compare in various aspects. Here’s a breakdown of how the Ninja FG551 and IG651 stack up against each other.
1. Cooking Functions:
Both the Ninja FG551 and IG651 offer multiple cooking modes. However, the IG651 has more preset options, making it easier to switch between grilling, air frying, and other functions. If you’re someone who loves convenience, the IG651’s presets can simplify your cooking experience.
2. Temperature Control:
The IG651 provides more precise temperature control, which is essential for cooking delicate foods like fish or chicken. The FG551 has a decent temperature range but doesn’t offer as many customization options as the IG651.
3. Cooking Capacity:
When it comes to cooking capacity, the IG651 takes the lead. It has a larger cooking area, allowing you to cook for 6 to 8 servings at once, while the FG551 is better suited for 4 to 5 servings. The IG651 also features multi-layer cooking, which allows you to prepare larger meals in one go.
4. Build Quality:
Both grills are made from durable materials, but the IG651 feels more premium thanks to its high-quality construction. The FG551, while sturdy, is made from a combination of plastic and metal.
5. Cleaning and Maintenance:
Both grills are easy to clean, with non-stick, dishwasher-safe parts. However, the IG651 edges out the FG551 in this category, as it offers more removable parts, making it even easier to clean.
6. Performance:
In terms of cooking performance, the IG651 is faster and more consistent. It handles a wider variety of foods with better results, thanks to its advanced sensors and controls. The FG551 performs well but doesn’t offer the same level of precision or speed.
7. Ease of Use:
The FG551 is simple to operate, while the IG651 comes with a more advanced interface. The latter might take some time to get used to, but the benefits are worth it once you master the controls.
8. Value for Money:
The FG551 is the more affordable option, but it lacks some of the features that make the IG651 a more complete appliance. If you’re looking for more flexibility and better overall performance, the IG651 justifies its higher price tag.
Final Verdict:
After using both the Ninja FG551 and IG651, I can confidently say that the IG651 offers more advanced features and better overall performance. If you’re someone who enjoys grilling but also likes to experiment with different cooking methods, the IG651 is a clear winner. That being said, the FG551 is an excellent choice if you’re looking for a simple, affordable, and effective indoor grill.
Conclusion
Ultimately, choosing between the Ninja FG551 and IG651 depends on your cooking style and needs. Both grills perform well and offer great value for money, but the IG651 provides more features and versatility. If you have the budget for it and want a more advanced cooking experience, I highly recommend the IG651. However, if you’re looking for something more straightforward and budget-friendly, the FG551 won’t disappoint.
“The best way to predict the future is to create it.” – Abraham Lincoln
In the world of kitchen gadgets, choosing the right appliance can certainly shape the future of your cooking experience.
FAQs: Ninja FG551 vs IG651
1. Which is better, Ninja FG551 or IG651?
Both grills are excellent, but the best option depends on your needs. The FG551 is perfect if you’re looking for a straightforward grilling experience with a few added functions like air frying and roasting. On the other hand, the IG651 offers more advanced features, like precise temperature control and a wider variety of cooking functions, making it better for those who want more flexibility and control in the kitchen.
2. Can both the Ninja FG551 and IG651 air fry?
Yes, both the Ninja FG551 and IG651 are capable of air frying. The FG551 provides basic air frying, while the IG651 offers more preset options, making it a bit more versatile in that department.
3. Is the Ninja IG651 worth the extra cost?
If you value precision, versatility, and advanced features, the IG651 is worth the extra cost. It provides more control over cooking temperatures, offers more cooking modes, and has a larger cooking capacity. However, if you don’t need all those extra features, the FG551 is a great choice and offers excellent value for money.
4. Do the Ninja FG551 and IG651 require preheating?
Yes, both models require preheating to ensure the best cooking results. The IG651 preheats faster due to its advanced technology, which can be a time-saver if you’re in a hurry.
5. Which one is easier to clean, Ninja FG551 or IG651?
Both models feature non-stick grill plates that are dishwasher-safe, making cleaning relatively easy. However, the IG651 is a bit easier to clean due to its additional removable parts, which simplifies the process even further.
6. Can I use the Ninja IG651 for dehydrating food?
Yes, the Ninja IG651 can dehydrate food, which adds another layer of versatility to the appliance. This feature is not available on the FG551, so if you’re interested in dehydrating fruits, vegetables, or meats, the IG651 would be the better option.
7. How much space does the Ninja IG651 require on the countertop?
The Ninja IG651 is a bit larger than the FG551, so it will require more counter space. If you have a smaller kitchen or limited countertop space, this might be something to consider before purchasing.
8. Which model is better for larger families?
The Ninja IG651 is better for larger families or gatherings as it has a bigger cooking capacity, able to cook 6-8 servings at once. The FG551, while adequate for smaller meals, is best suited for 4-5 servings.
9. Are there any warranties on the Ninja FG551 and IG651?
Both the Ninja FG551 and IG651 come with a manufacturer warranty, typically covering defects in material and workmanship. It’s always a good idea to check the warranty details on the official Ninja website or consult the user manual for specific coverage information.
